Collaborative Decision Making
In a complex, connected and ever-changing world the need for leaders to excel at collaborative decision making is more critical than ever. It's not often that one will find collaboration without some degree of conflict; however, through collaboration, most challenges are greatly diminished.
A specific situation where I was faced with a difficult decision was when I had to demote an employee due to harassment. As a director, one of my responsibilities is to ensure that all employees are free from all forms of discrimination and harassment. In my organization, all complaints must be taken seriously and investigated immediately. When I was first made aware of the charge, I involved the human resources department because of my organization's protocol. During the investigation, the accuser asked me if something was going on that he should know about and I merely stated no. Understand this is someone I worked closely with and felt awful for not telling the truth; however, I could not disrespect the policies that were being enforced.
Days passed, and the said employee began to miss work and report to work late more frequently. I could tell the employee was pretty worried about the investigation. One day while entering into an elevator with the said employee he asked if I had been honest with him because my disposition had become very distant. At that moment I conveyed to him that there had been allegations of harassment and I was informed only to discuss direct questions concerning his scope of work. The employee became very upset, disgruntled and even made a complaint that he was being tried unfairly. While none of this employee statement was correct, I think as a leader I could have handled him differently.
When I look back at this unfortunate situation I am reminded that as a leader one is required to make tough decisions; however, a tough stance is not necessary for doing so. The approach of not giving the employee some type of answer would have lead to a better resolution. The employee was demoted for two reasons harassment and insubordination. Had I not avoided answering the employee's question, the outcome of him having an outburst may not have occurred contributing to his demotion.
In this scenario, the only stakeholders involved were the two employees and the one human resource manager. I think had I not listened to the HR manager and merely told the employee that an investigation was underway, a collaboration of how to move forward in conflict could have taken
place.
This experience helped me grow as a leader. I have learned that although allegations had been made, every employee still has the right to be treated fairly during an investigation. Three takeaways from this experience were
- Be straightforward and transparent
- Be understanding and slow to judge
- Ask somebody with more experience about their decisions and how they
approached any similar situations.
True collaboration requires managing information, analysis, and responsibility from the initiation of an issue right to the final decision and follow-through. It means bringing the right people together and enabling them to work collectively from the same information source: to wrestle with the various alternatives and ultimately develop a shared understanding and mutual commitment to a particular course of action (Littleson, 2008). As a leader when we have such a myopic view, we tend to do what is best for us, ignoring those around us. Moving forward, using all resources available for handling conflict and involving key stakeholders will be paramount to ensure collaboration takes place and is effective.
References:
Hoch, S.J., & Kunreuther, H.C. (2005). Wharton on making decisions. (1st ed.). Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Littleson, Randy (2008). Collaborative decision making requires a collaboration of capabilities. Retrieved from http://www.edn.com/electronics-blogs/other/4327620/Collaborative-decision-making-requires-a-collaboration-of-capab
In a complex, connected and ever-changing world the need for leaders to excel at collaborative decision making is more critical than ever. It's not often that one will find collaboration without some degree of conflict; however, through collaboration, most challenges are greatly diminished.
A specific situation where I was faced with a difficult decision was when I had to demote an employee due to harassment. As a director, one of my responsibilities is to ensure that all employees are free from all forms of discrimination and harassment. In my organization, all complaints must be taken seriously and investigated immediately. When I was first made aware of the charge, I involved the human resources department because of my organization's protocol. During the investigation, the accuser asked me if something was going on that he should know about and I merely stated no. Understand this is someone I worked closely with and felt awful for not telling the truth; however, I could not disrespect the policies that were being enforced.
Days passed, and the said employee began to miss work and report to work late more frequently. I could tell the employee was pretty worried about the investigation. One day while entering into an elevator with the said employee he asked if I had been honest with him because my disposition had become very distant. At that moment I conveyed to him that there had been allegations of harassment and I was informed only to discuss direct questions concerning his scope of work. The employee became very upset, disgruntled and even made a complaint that he was being tried unfairly. While none of this employee statement was correct, I think as a leader I could have handled him differently.When I look back at this unfortunate situation I am reminded that as a leader one is required to make tough decisions; however, a tough stance is not necessary for doing so. The approach of not giving the employee some type of answer would have lead to a better resolution. The employee was demoted for two reasons harassment and insubordination. Had I not avoided answering the employee's question, the outcome of him having an outburst may not have occurred contributing to his demotion.
In this scenario, the only stakeholders involved were the two employees and the one human resource manager. I think had I not listened to the HR manager and merely told the employee that an investigation was underway, a collaboration of how to move forward in conflict could have taken place.
This experience helped me grow as a leader. I have learned that although allegations had been made, every employee still has the right to be treated fairly during an investigation. Three takeaways from this experience were
- Be straightforward and transparent
- Be understanding and slow to judge
- Ask somebody with more experience about their decisions and how they
approached any similar situations.
True collaboration requires managing information, analysis, and responsibility from the initiation of an issue right to the final decision and follow-through. It means bringing the right people together and enabling them to work collectively from the same information source: to wrestle with the various alternatives and ultimately develop a shared understanding and mutual commitment to a particular course of action (Littleson, 2008). As a leader when we have such a myopic view, we tend to do what is best for us, ignoring those around us. Moving forward, using all resources available for handling conflict and involving key stakeholders will be paramount to ensure collaboration takes place and is effective.References:
Hoch, S.J., & Kunreuther, H.C. (2005). Wharton on making decisions. (1st ed.). Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Littleson, Randy (2008). Collaborative decision making requires a collaboration of capabilities. Retrieved from http://www.edn.com/electronics-blogs/other/4327620/Collaborative-decision-making-requires-a-collaboration-of-capab

Comments
Post a Comment